Kensington and Chelsea Council’s planning committee last week turned down the practice’s proposals for the superstore site at 100 West Cromwell Road – a plot with a complex planning history stretching back more than a decade.
McAslan’s 427-home scheme for investment firm Meyer Bergman and development manager Londonewcastle includes eight buildings of up to 22 storeys.
The latest proposals for the 1.7ha site included an increase in affordable housing from 11 per cent to 35 per cent as well as a community leisure hall and a gym with swimming pool.
But councillors raised concerns over the quality of the proposed housing and the scale of the development, which they argued would ‘overshadow’ residents in the neighbouring Warren House.
An officers’ report recommending refusal described the development as comprising a ‘range of excessively tall and over-scaled buildings that serve to dominate the immediate context’.
John McAslan Architects is the fourth architect to draw up plans for the site, with its plans replacing Benson + Forsyth Architects’ competition-winning scheme for Spenhill Developments, approved in 2017.
Benson + Forsyth was selected following an architectural competition, held in 2009, and judged by representatives from the council and government design watchdog CABE.
John McAslan was also on the shortlist that time, along with Peter Barber, Fielden Clegg Bradley Studios, David Chipperfield and Denton Corker Marshall.
However, the scheme was abandoned following the sale of the site to Meyer Bergman, which has since criticised the designs as ’outdated’ and including ‘complicated buildings that were difficult to build’.
Benson + Forsyth itself replaced Bolles + Wilson, which had designed a scheme for Brookfield Multiplex that was later withdrawn. The AJ reported at the time that the developer had come under pressure from the local authority to change its high-rise designs.
Another 27-storey scheme designed by Woods Bagot for housebuilder Persimmon Homes was turned down by the council in 2007.
A Kensington and Chelsea spokesperson said: ‘Committee rejected this large development for a range of reasons, with the chair of the committee particularly noting the impact it would have on residents in Warren House, a property the scheme would literally overshadow.’
John McAslan Architects and Meyer Bergman were approached for comment.